Beyond their structural advantages, index funds also stand out when viewed through the lens of real-world performance and investor behaviour across market segments.
For instance, many investors believe that active management should work better in the mid- and small-cap space, actual outcomes tell a more nuanced story.
In the midcap and smallcap segments, allocation to passive funds (which include index funds and ETFs) remains extremely low, at just 4% in mid caps and 3% in small caps (AMFI. Data as of February 2026). Many investors believe that these segments offer greater inefficiencies and, therefore, better opportunities for skilled fund managers to generate alpha. As a result, active funds continue to dominate investor allocations in these categories.
However, actual performance outcomes challenge this belief. Over the last three years, only 38% of active midcap funds and 25% of active smallcap funds have outperformed their respective market benchmarks (AMFI, Data as of February 2026). In other words, even in segments where active management is expected to shine, consistent outperformance has been difficult and highly unpredictable.
In contrast, in the ‑largecap space, passive funds (index funds and ETFs) account for nearly 65% of large-cap exposure (AMFI. Data as of February 2026), reflecting growing confidence in passive investing.
This is mainly because large companies are well researched and information about them is easy to find, leaving little room to earn extra returns. As a result, low-cost passive funds that track the market are often seen as a smart and efficient choice.
Interestingly, performance data shows that about 73% of active largecap‑ funds have managed to outperform their benchmarks over the last three years (AMFI, Data as of February 2026).
Source: AMFI. Data as of February 2026
This gap between expectations and outcomes highlights a key reality of investing. While active funds can outperform in certain periods, keeping track of those winners in advance — and staying invested through inevitable phases of underperformance is far from easy. Many investors end up redeeming funds at the wrong time, eroding returns in the process.
Index funds don’t rely on manager skill or timing decisions. Instead, they ensure steady participation in the market’s growth, making them especially effective as a core portfolio holding within a long-term portfolio, and providing you an opportunity to diverse your portfolio.