Active or index funds: Which should you choose?

Active vs index funds – which should you choose? This article breaks down what each option offers, their pros and cons, and help investors make informed asset allocation decisions.

Published on 8 January 2026

4 min read

Index and Active funds

When designing an investment portfolio, one of the key decisions investors face is how to allocate their assets across different security types to create a comprehensive investment portfolio. Mutual funds are comprehensive investment vehicles which can help investors to design their investment portfolios keeping in mind diversification, simplicity and cost. Depending on the risk appetite, investment objectives and time horizon, an investment portfolio can be designed using active mutual funds, index mutual funds or a combination of both. Each approach offers distinct advantages and trade-offs. In this article, we explain what active and index funds are, how they work, and the pros and cons of each in helping investors to make informed asset allocation decisions.

Index funds aim to replicate the performance of a market index, such as the NIFTY 50 or NIFTY Midcap. They aim to match the market, not beat it, and can be structured either as mutual funds or ETFs (exchange traded funds).

Active funds are mutual funds or ETFs managed by professional fund managers which aim to outperform a specific benchmark index. Professional fund managers use research, market trends and economic indicators to make investing decisions. The goal is generating alpha, or returns above the benchmark. This comes with high costs, volatility and the risk of underperformance.

The pros and cons of each type of fund are summarised below:

	Index funds	Active funds
Pros	Track a specific index, efficiently providing broad market exposure. Perform reliably by replicating the index without taking active risk. Are low-cost option. Selection depending on asset allocation in conjunction with other building blocks.	Can potentially generate high returns vs. a benchmark. Are able to outperform by capitalising on market opportunities and managing risks. Can uncover hidden opportunities and avoid poorly performing stocks.
Cons	Cannot beat the market; returns are capped at the index level. Will fall along with the index during any stock market downturns.	Reliant on the skills and judgement of portfolio managers. Large fund sizes can dilute management flexibility. Strong past performance does not guarantee future returns, making consistency uncertain. Are usually more expensive.

Bottom line: Your plan matters more than the fund label

Choosing between active and index funds is one step in a much bigger journey. Positive outcomes stem from how well your investments align with your risk profile, personal goals and timeframe. Both index and active mutual funds can have a place in your investment portfolio. But being aware of the benefits of each can help you invest with clarity.

Don’t leave it to guesswork. If you’re unsure, consult a SEBI Registered Investment Adviser. They can help you assess your risk profile, build a personalised investment plan and can advice the right blend of mutual funds to keep you on track with your investment objectives.

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only.